Bands That Crapped Out
Listen
Summary
Drew and Doug settle into the dry, cozy Voice of Vashon studio on a rare rainy day to run a theme show: bands that crapped out. For each band they play one song from the good years and then one from after the fall, with both hosts stressing that this is strictly an opinion piece. Along the way Doug brings two rounds of Weird News, there is a brief bell-off, and the hosts disagree more than once about which half of a pair is actually the crap half.
Segments
0:00:57 Opening — Drew introduces his dad Doug, who gives a somber "That's me." It is dumping rain outside, but Doug notes there are no leaks in the "vast voluminous studios" of the Voice of Vashon.
0:01:57 The theme — Drew has a clean version of the theme: bands that went to crap. One good song, then one abysmal song, by the same band. Both hosts added picks and both insist it is purely their own tastes.
0:03:13 First pair: a fresh wound — Drew picks Bellingham's Death Cab for Cutie, whose upcoming eighth LP he had preordered on vinyl and has since cancelled. After the two songs, Doug compares the new single's drums to three different rooms and both groan at a sampled clap. Drew says a founding member left the band, and he and his friend Rob suspect this record is why. Drew has preordered Courtney Barnett's record instead.
0:17:02 Second pair — Drew's pick, chosen for the sheer gap between the good and bad songs. Doug says thirty seconds into the bad one he was looking for the abort button, and felt like he was in a dance club on Maui in 1984. The hosts land on "sellouts" as the term.
0:30:16 Third pair — Doug's pick, a San Francisco ’60s psychedelic band and its later incarnation. Doug says the first song reeks of the 60s, the second was glitzy 80s and perfect for MTV. Full disclosure: Doug played the bad one in a cover band.
0:39:55 Weird News — Zombie apocalypse simulations and the hosts' theory that zombies cannot make noise because they do not breathe. Drew has not seen the current season of a zombie show because he is waiting to watch it with his mother. Doug and Kathy binged a new comedy series the night before, and the hosts compare favorite running gags.
0:44:14 Fourth pair — A guitarist who started in another San Francisco band in the 60s and later phoned in a hugely successful late-90s hit. Doug saw him live on Maui in 1982 with backstage passes, a great show. Both saw him at the Tacoma Dome and found it too long.
0:55:52 Fifth pair — Another fresh wound for Drew: a band with a new album out this month. Doug thought both songs were crap, Drew only the second. Drew objects that it reuses guitar harmonics from the band's biggest hit and leans on the same four pop chords. Doug recommends the week's other Voice of Vashon shows and underwriters.
1:05:52 Bells — Last week the hosts said they needed a bell. This week they both showed up with one. Drew claims the better bell.
1:06:06 Weird News — Legislators versus science: a Nevada assemblywoman's baking-soda cancer bill, and an Idaho representative's swallowed-camera question. Drew calls it maybe one of the dumbest things he has ever heard. Doug declines to name Washington's own wingnuts, not wanting to get yelled at crossing the street after the show.
1:10:24 Sixth pair — A band Drew loved as a little kid. Doug recalls being on a tugboat when four-year-old Drew mailed him a cassette of their album. Afterward Doug counts seven guitar players since the original left, and Drew hears a melody lifted from a pop singer's hit. Doug pictures the bad song over Adam Sandler movie credits, which Drew briefly believes was real.
1:21:41 Seventh pair — A long, good Rolling Stones track ("Can't You Hear Me Knockin'") and then a dance mix Drew calls possibly the worst song of theirs he has ever heard. Doug talks tuning and how learning the lead drove him crazy until he worked out it was also in open G.
1:37:32 Eighth pair — A band and its frontman, grouped together because, as Doug puts it, the band was basically him with sidemen. Afterward the hosts read the bad song's lyrics aloud with mock reverence. Drew saw the frontman with another icon at Key Arena about a year ago and loved it. Both hosts saw the two Pauls on the SNL 40th and were unimpressed. Doug's language gets a bit salty and both remember they are now on FM, not just online.
1:48:23 Ninth pair — Doug's pick, which Drew is surprised exists because he assumed the band had no good songs. The good one reminds Doug of riding a ski lift in high school. Drew thinks the bad one sounds like the opening of a bad musical. Doug blames letting a keyboard player front a band.
1:59:43 Sign-off — "one hour of pain and one hour of decent music." Back next Sunday with possibly a new theme.
Tune in, or don’t™
Tracklist
| Time | Song | Artist | Album |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:22 | Prove My Hypothesis | Death Cab for Cutie | |
| 7:46 | Black Sun | Death Cab for Cutie | Kintsugi |
| 17:48 | Three Seed | Silver Sun Pickups | Carnivoss |
| 27:09 | The Pit | Silver Sun Pickups | |
| 30:56 | Somebody to Love | Jefferson Airplane | |
| 44:32 | Oye Como Va | Santana | |
| 57:15 | Ocean Breeze Salty | Modest Mouse | |
| 1:03:37 | Lampshades on Fire | Modest Mouse | Strangers to Ourselves |
| 1:11:47 | Walking on the Sun | Smash Mouth | |
| 1:14:04 | Walkin' On the Sun | Smash Mouth | Smash Mouth |
| 1:15:10 | Magic (feat. J. Dash) | Smash Mouth | Magic (Deluxe Edition) |
| 1:22:23 | Can't You Hear Me Knockin' | The Rolling Stones | |
| 1:38:09 | Roxanne | The Police | |
| 1:49:22 | Lady | Styx | |
| 1:52:18 | Mr. Roboto | Styx |